Reindeer Treats


Today I want to share these Reindeer Treats with you…

These will make some yummy Christmas treats that would be fun for a family party, classroom treat, or small gift.  They would also be a fun Christmas cookie to take to a Christmas cookie exchange.


These were pretty easy to make. We tooks some Nutter Butter Cookies and separated the top and bottom cookies to reveal the peanut butter filling inside. Then we added a little more creamy peanut butter and stuck a new popsicle stick in the peanut butter.


Then we put the tops back on. We did this to several and then lined a cookie sheet with some wax paper to placed the reindeer pops on after we dip them in chocolate.


After dipping the cookies in chocolate we laid them onto the wax paper. Then before the chocolate hardens add your reindeer faces. We used white chocolate chips for the eyes and a dot of black icing for the pupil (if you want the eyes to sit flat, cut the pointy tip off the chocolate chip with kitchen scissors or a knife). We used red M&M’s for the nose and added some sprinkles to the cheeks. Then we used broken pretzels for the antlers.


The antlers can be a bit tricky to get to stick. We found the easiest way to get them to stay put was to place the end of one of the antlers (pretzel) on top of the head and then cover the end with melted chocolate. Repeat this for the other antler. Then we placed the reindeer into the freezer so they would harden. Make sure to lay your cookie sheet flat.

Easy-Christmas-Treats |

Once they have hardened, you will be able to wrap them up cute and give them away…or eat them! And since I love Peanut Butter and Chocolate…these were pretty tasty!


  1. House of Smiths says

    I seriously love this cute idea! Where do you GET this stuff, girl!
    ~Shelley Smith

  2. this blessed nest says

    this is adorable! so wonderful & clever. my kiddos are gonna love these!

    have a super week…from your fellow survivor die-hard fan! ;)


  3. ilovedolly says

    Mmmmm if only we got those peanut biscuits here in the UK. They look delicious, even without their amazingly cute reindeer covering. Must try similar – really into pops at the moment

  4. Janine says

    I saw your post over there earlier this week. Just love it!!! Keep those ideas coming xxx

  5. southerninspiration says

    Adorable!!! We used to make something similar with spoons and tootsie rolls, but who doesn't love Nutter Butters!!! So why did you add extra peanut butter…did you need it to be "fuller"?
    Cute, cute, cute!


  6. CK says

    Awesome, awesome, awesome, awesome holiday ideas! Reindeers, cornucopia, thank you notes in bread???? awesome!


  7. Shannon says

    Oh my word…I will be making these for my son's teachers (and he will be helping me)! PRECIOUS!

  8. Angie - The Arthur Clan says

    Oh my goodness…these are adorable! My kids will love making these for school party treats. :)

    P.S. Thank you so much for your kind comment about my Thanksgiving Boat Treat Holders. They were super fun to make!

  9. R and N says

    I just finished making a batch of these cute cookies this weekend. I love the idea and they taste wonderful. Thanks for sharing.

  10. says

    LOVE these ! know it is a year old, but these are amazing!! I am you newest follower! I’d love for you to follow me back, if you want to =-)

  11. beth hallowell says

    how do you melt the chocolate? I’m not super food crafty so want to make sure I do it right


  1. […] the Editor: Adorable reindeer pops (looks pretty easy to make too!) via The Idea […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *